The Great Writ

Welcome to The Great Writ. We hope this blog on habeas corpus and post conviction relief will be a useful resource for those of you interested in this area of the law.


habeas-corpus

  • Status Updates

    Now that the semester is winding down, I finally have some time to take a look at the status of the remaining habeas cases involving student and faculty activists. Specifically, I am referring to the cases of Mahmoud Khalil, Rumeysa Ozturk, Mohsen Mahdawi, and Badar Khan Suri. All four sought habeas corpus protection in federal Continue reading

  • W.M.M. Redux

    The Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals recently granted a petition from the Government seeking a rehearing en banc in W.M.M. v. Trump.  Because there still is a habeas corpus aspect to this case – and a suggestion by the dissent in the panel opinion that class certification isn’t appropriate for habeas cases – it is worth looking at the Continue reading

  • Rivers v. Guerrero

    In the flurry of habeas corpus cases involving student protestors filed and argued during the spring and summer, I neglected to comment on a U.S. Supreme Court decision from last June – Rivers v. Guerrero. Rivers is a technical habeas corpus case involving sequential filings made while other filings were still pending. Following a conviction in Texas state Continue reading

  • Expanding Habeas Rights?

    Proponents of habeas corpus have been fighting a losing battle against those seeking to restrict the writ to its narrowest possible application.  The biggest blow to habeas was certainly wielded by Congress with the passage of the AEDPA in 1996.  Since then, the Supreme Court has contributed to the demise of the writ by steadily narrowing the Continue reading

  • Habeas Corpus and Class Certification

    Yesterday I had the privilege of participating in a panel discussion co-sponsored by Ohio Northern University’s and Mississippi College’s Colleges of Law on AARP(WMM) v. Trump.  This panel discussion had been planned well ahead of time but, as luck would have it, the 5th Circuit Court of Appeals issued their ruling on the motion for a preliminary hearing Continue reading

  • My final historical post

    This last historical post is more consistent with the types of habeas issues that have predominated in this blog over time – a use of habeas to challenge a criminal conviction. It was first published on July 28. The Second Circuit Court of Appeals issued an interesting habeas corpus opinion on Monday in Hernandez v. McIntosh. Continue reading

  • Wrapping up – Part 8

    The post below was an attempt to give a status update on the student deportations cases. It was originally published on June 27. Now that the dust has settled somewhat from the flurry of cases involving what I will refer to as “academic activists” who were detained by the Government and who subsequently filed habeas Continue reading

  • A Step Back in Time – Part 7

    In the continuing process of migrating some of my more recent and relevant posts to this new platform I offer a post I published on June 4 regarding the litigation surround Khalil. Last week, in Khalil v. Trump, Judge Farbiarz issued a 106-page order and opinion denying in part and granting in part (sort of) Khalil’s motion for Continue reading

  • A Step back in History – Part 5

    Perhaps the most newsworthy story in the Ozturk case came when she was released from detention in Louisiana and permitted to return to Massachusetts. The following post was published on May 12. Last week two significant decisions were made in the Ozturk v. Trump case. On Wednesday, the Second Circuit Court of Appeals denied the Government’s request for a stay Continue reading

  • A Step back in History – Part 4

    The Khalil case is the “poster boy” case for the government’s attempt to deport student activists protesting Israel. Khalil was a fairly high profile figure during the protests at Columbia in New York. He was the first of several students detained by ICE. His case may involve the most voluminous examination of a variety of Continue reading